(UPDATED BELOW)
I heard a friend this morning ask aloud, "How can we have voted in Barack Obama by such a wide margin here in California and yet also vote to ban gay marriage?" It's a valid question. Here we voted to give chickens more rights in their cages but not to keep what I think is a fundamental right for human beings.
I haven't looked at all the numbers yet, and it will be awhile before we see the most accurate, specific demographic breakdown we can get, but here's one stab at it. And this is NOT meant to blame/scapegoat in any way, simply trying to better understand how this can happen. There was a large turnout of African American voters and Latino voters here, as well as nationwide, which is fantastic. While those voters turned out huge for Obama, many of them (again this is just speaking broadly) are also fairly religious and even traditional churchgoers, and in many respects vote in the traditional values set on social issues even when voting progressive for individual people and on other issues (economic, environmental). Again, this is just a guess, but it's possible that may have been one difference in the vote on Proposition 8 here in California. (That and the incredible amount of funding that the Yes on 8 campaign had in their coffers, almost all of it from out of state people -- I can't tell you how much I resent that.) Clearly, a ton of white folks voted for this proposition, too. A lot of misinformation about it was spread, fear-mongering about teaching school kids to be gay/accept gay marriage, when that had nothing to do with it at all. So there is plenty of blame to go around on this one. I live in a bubble here in San Francisco where it of course was voted down overwhelmingly, and am just trying to understand.
It does make me a bit sad if true that while we took a huge step forward in civil rights for people of color yesterday with this monumental Presidential election, we here in California have a divide when it comes to civil rights for gay people. Until those ideals become all-encompassing, it's clear we still have a ways to go.
One giant leap for man yesterday, one step backwards for man (and woman)kind, too.
UPDATE:
Michael Musto in the Village Voice seems to agree with my guess, though in more emotional terms.
Also: Here's a picture of some of the people, in Orange County, who were avid supporters of Prop 8. In case you, you know, want to photoshop that photo to put them all in lavender or something cathartic like that.
Lastly, here's a list -- it's public record -- of people who donated large to Yes on Prop. 8. Know any of them? Feel free to give them a piece of your mind.
2nd UPDATE (11/7):
More optimistic note from Todd Palmer and Rob Pringle, on how the demographic reflects that 61% of voters under 30 voted against 8 and an even higher percentage of voters under age of 24. Most of the "Yes"s came from older voters, so the hope would be that homophobia dies with them. And they note that it's unfair to blame the African American vote for turning the tide when that's only 6% of the electorate.)
AND: A really thoughtful email from the No on 8 coalition which also cautions against scapegoating and blaming. Please read.
Dear Craig,
This has been an incredibly difficult week for Californians who
are disappointed in the passage of Proposition 8, which takes
away the right to marry for same-sex couples in our state. We
feel a profound sense of disappointment in this defeat, but know
that in order to move forward we must continue to stand together
as one community in order to secure full equality in
California.
In working to defeat Prop 8, a profound coalition banded
together to fight for equality. Faith leaders, labor, teachers,
civil rights leaders and communities of color, Republicans,
Democrats, and Independents, public officials, local school
boards and city councils, parents, corporate law firms and bar
associations, businesses, and people from all walks of life
joined together to stand up against discrimination. We must
build on this coalition in order to achieve equal rights for all
Californians.
We achieve nothing if we isolate the people who did not stand
with us in this fight. We only further divide our state if we
attempt to blame people of faith, African American voters, rural
communities and others for this loss. We know people of all
faiths, races and backgrounds stand with us in our fight to end
discrimination, and will continue to do so. Now more than ever
it is critical that we work together and respect our differences
that make us a diverse and unique society. Only with that
understanding will we achieve justice and equality for all.
![]()
Dr. Delores A. Jacobs
CEO
Center Advocacy Project |
![]()
Lorri L. Jean
CEO
L.A. Gay & Lesbian Center |
![]() Kate Kendell
Executive Director
National Center for Lesbian Rights |
![]() Geoff Kors
Executive Director
Equality California |
Recent Comments